The Rule of Prejudicial Error: when VA mistakes aren't really mistakes.

Rule of Prejudicial ErrorIn any case before the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC), the Rule of Prejudicial Error could well come into play.  

What is the "Rule of Prejudicial Error"?

Congress has written the so-called "harmless error" statute (28 U.S.C. § 2111), which requires courts to review cases for errors of law, without regard to errors that do not affect a party's substantial rights.

The idea was to make sure that Federal Appeals Courts didn't turn into - their words - "impregnable citadels of technicality".  

In reality, it just creates one more hoop that Veteran and their surviving spouses have to jump through - a showing that a Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA) error effectively altered the outcome of the case (i.e., harmed the Veteran).

Here is a scenario that shows the Rule of Prejudicial Error in effect.

Veterans CourtA surviving spouse sought survivor's benefits when her husband (a Veteran) committed suicide.

 She argued that her husband's PTSD caused his suicide, and that the VA Regional Office failed in its Duty to Assist in providing her a  medical opinion to determine whether this was the case.  The court agreed that the VA Regional Office erred when it did not provide a medical opinion to the surviving spouse.

However, because the Court could find no evidence that the Veteran had been diagnosed with PTSD, it concluded that the error was harmless - essentially, it concluded that no medical opinion could connect an undiagnosed condition to the Veteran's cause of death.

Here's my Problem with the Rule of Prejudicial Error.

My problem with the Rule of Prejudicial Error is two-fold.

First, it requires a Veteran or a Veteran's survivor to deal with more legal mumbo-jumbo in a scheme that is already overwhelmingly inaccessible.  

Lawyers are taught to argue, and many of us are quite good (some better than others) at developing an argument that  our client's mistake really didn't hurt another party.  

Vets and their survivors are mostly pro-se, and find these arguments overwhelmingly complex to challenge.

Second, the VA Regional Office is an administration built on error or mistake.  (Seriously - look "error" up in the Dictionary, and there is a picture of the VA Headquarters building right there).

When talking to Veterans, I often tell them that the best advice is to assume that the VA Regional Office made an error; chances are greater than not that they did.  

In fact, pick 10 random ratings decision, or 10 random Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA) decisions, and I'd bet you can find an obvious error in 80% of them.   Until the VA Regional Office shows that it can properly interpret and apply the  law, and treat Veterans with fairness and quickly dispatch their claims, the Rule of Prejudicial Error should be suspended in VA Regional Office claims.

What can a Veteran do about the Rule of Prejudicial Error? 

How does a Veteran or surviving spouse protect themselves from an unfair (or improper) application of the Rule of Prejudicial Error?

The first thing you can do is this:

hiring a VA Disability Claim Attorney1) Learn the 8 Steps to Improve Your VA Claim.  By getting knowledge, information and power EARLIER in your claim, you can side-step almost all of the errors that lead to this problem.

2) As soon as the VA Regional Office, or BVA, asserts the Rule of Prejudicial Error, start talking to professional advocates.  I don't write this blog to "get clients" - I write this blog to inform and educate - to give Veterans Power in their VA Claims.  There are a lot of good attorneys out there that represent Veterans.  Check out my FREE Veterans Law Guidebook to learn practical tips on how to choose the Veterans Benefits attorney that is right for your claim. 


Categories: #2 Move, #3 Communicate

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Hello, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
When I look at your website in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has
some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!

Other then that, awesome blog!

Chris Attig says:

Thanks for the heads up! My IT guys are actually recoding the site for a new look, so I’ll let them know!


Search Our Blog

Which eBook Package is Right For You?

Popup Package Comparison2
how to file a va claim
Testimonial HTFAVAC Mike O Google+

 "[Y]our Ebooks would be my 1st step, if I had to do [my claim] all over again....Ask me now what I think your Ebooks and Documents are worth.....saved me a year or 2 on BVA appeal and at least $15K in legal fees."   

- George D. (Veteran)



"You explain in plain language what works and what doesn't and why it doesn't. Your E-Book ... on Lay and medical evidence is fantastic and easy to follow." 

- James F (Vietnam Veteran)


 Screenshot 2015-03-07 13.12.18


VA Claims Sleep Apnea Package





VA TDIU eBook Package








Are you New Here?

#1: See the Problem.

#2: Get Your C-File

#3: Learn the Law

#4: Build the 4 Pillars

#5: Use 5-Star Evidence

#6: Choose your Battlefield

#7: Get Help

#8: Protect Survivors & Dependents