I had mixed feelings when A-Rod showed up in the Bronx after the 2003 season. On one hand, he is arguably the best active player in the game. On the other hand, I always agreed with Dave Winfield that a team with too many superstars can’t win. After this last post-season, I have no problem saying “So long, A-Rod”.
Now that he’s gone - for good, I hope - I’m ecstatic. Yes, he added a lot of runs, RBI’s and homers to the Yankees offense. But the run generation never seemed to carry over into the post-season. Yes, except for 2006, he was a steady glove at the hot-corner. But we won more post-season games with Brosius and Hayes at 3B than we did with A-Rod.
I don’t know how to articulate why I’m glad he’s gone - except to say that I think that it was too easy for the front-office to rely on his run generation as an excuse not to bolster the starting pitching and the bullpen. Taking his bat out of the Bombers’ lineup means that we’ll have to find better pitching to keep the scores lower.
It may take a season or two, but the loss of A-Rod might actually give us a chance to see something other than Kyle Farnsworth-less, Myers, Proctor or Sturtze come out of the bullpen. It may give us a chance to see a better back end of the rotation than the parade of no-names, has-beens and wanna-bes that have filled the number 4 and 5 slots since 2004. And it may give us a chance to see a 3B’man that focuses on winning in the post-season instead of winning in the stats.
For those chances, I’m more than ecstatic about seeing A-Rod go and bleed Dodger Blue (or, given his salary demands, Bleed the Dodgers’ Green). So long, A-Rod.